Sarasota's best Burger

The 15 Best Burgers in Sarasota

Posted on: June 27, 2017

From brilliant mash-ups to simple classics, the 15 best burgers in Sarasota

Indigenous’ My Uncle’s Burger

Chef Steve Phelps’ revered downtown Sarasota fine dining establishment has little in common with Swensons, an Akron, Ohio, drive-in, except for this burger. As a youngster in the Cleveland restaurant industry, Phelps used to drive to Akron to down Swensons patties, but he never could figure out what made them so special. Until, that is, one night when Phelps’ uncle got drunk with a Swensons insider and convinced him to spill the beans:

Swensons cuts its ground beef with frozen butter, a common trick, and it also adds honey. Voilà!

Phelps’ iteration of the Swensons burger swaps out the honey for maple syrup and drops in beef from humanely raised Niman Ranch cattle. A double patty is laced with cheddar cheese, a barbecue-aioli blend and a pepper-forward bacon jam. On the side sits a pile of leftover bits of carrots and onions and the like, which in other restaurants would go in the rubbish bin, but are here transformed into pickled condiment. (Word to the wise: Don’t even think about asking for substitutions. This burger is as thought-through as everything else on Phelps’ menu, and his small kitchen can’t handle variations.)

The result: a studly burger that nods to Phelps’ history in northeast Ohio as well as his ethical commitments. It’s high. It’s low. It’s tasty as hell. It’s Sarasota’s best burger.

The Steakhouse Burger at Alpine Steakhouse

Bypass the traditional bacon cheeseburger in favor of one stacked with pork jowl at Alpine Steakhouse, which gilds the lily with a couple of onion rings. The thick strips of jowl, what the Italians call guanciale, deliver intense smokiness, and the rich beef is ground in-house and cooked to the exact temperature you request. This bad boy isn’t always listed on the menu, but the staff promises you can order it anytime.

Made’s Eponymous Burger

No one would accuse Made chef Mark Woodruff of holding back. His dishes are decadent and bold, with a pileup of ingredients that walks the line between just enough and way too much. That goes for his signature burger, which includes (deep breath) high-end Niman Ranch beef, a tangle of barbacoa-style meat, sautéed red peppers and onions, a tart fried green tomato, cheese and lettuce, with a ramekin of the restaurant’s addictive homemade smoked ketchup on the side. You’ll never need to eat again.

The Caramelized Onion and Brie Burger at Shakespeare’s English Pub

A legend. This burger has been helping locals soak up the beer selection at Shakespeare’s for more than a decade. A nest of slowly cooked-down onions flavored with balsamic vinegar rests atop the meat and below an X of brie slices, and the whole thing is slid into a rosemary-scented bun and accented with lettuce, tomato and onion. The patties here are thick, allowing the cooks to develop thick, black skins on the outside while keeping the interiors bloody. This beauty will never go out of style.

State Street’s Fresh Ground Burger

Rather than serving straight-from-the-jar pickles and raw onions, State Street slices cucumbers and red onions into thin ribbons and pickles them in-house before throwing them on top of the meat and cheese. The pickling adds moisture and a hint of sweetness, contrasting with the richness of the fat and protein below. Another hit: the bun. Most times, the sesame seeds on a bun are little more than decoration. Here, that shower of seeds is powerful enough to add their flavor to the overall package.

The Capital Grille- Wild Mushroom Wagyu Cheeseburger

Of all the burgers on the list, this one might be the most exactly cooked. The trick: a patty as tall as an NBA player, which allows the exterior to crisp up while the inside remains juicy and red. It would be perfect even without the slice of Havarti and the cluster of mushrooms (sautéed until soft, but still possessing some chew), but those elements add some dazzle, as does a drizzle of 15-year-old balsamic vinegar. At $18, this is the most expensive burger we rated. And it’s worth every penny.

The Mighty Murf Burger at Michael’s On East

Some complicated burger creations fall apart under the weight of their pretensions. Not so this adventurous invention. The patty is a mix of bison, chorizo and mushrooms, a blend that foregrounds the spice of the pork sausage and prevents the lean bison meat from drying out. This thing is so juicy it’s a double-napkin dish. The innovative blend keeps throwing out surprises as you eat your way through it. An experiment that pays off.

The Hob Nob’s Classic Cheeseburger

Nothing creative here—just simple drive-in nostalgia, served lightning-quick in a red plastic basket lined with greasy wax paper. The Hob Nob’s smallish patties are thin, topped with gooey American cheese, rounds of crisp white onion, slabs of lettuce and a slice of tomato that’s actually red, all of it enclosed in a crisped bun daubed with mayo. It doesn’t sound like anything special, but the combination is off the charts, delivering a rush that will have you recalling sock hops you never attended and jalopy rides you never went on.

BurgerFi’s Conflicted Burger

Five Guys used to hold the title for best quick-fired chain burger in Sarasota, but based on a recent head-to-head, BurgerFi gets the nod these days. It’s the same basic setup: default double patties, quickly griddled and packed with whatever toppings you like. What sets it apart are fun change-ups like the Conflicted Burger, which combines a meat patty with a vegetarian one. The quinoa-based plant patty is good enough to eat on its own, but its vegetal notes are a nice addition to the juice and crispiness of its beefy companion. No need to feel guilty for making your order a double.

Daily Eats’ Namesake Burger

Daily Eats brings a DIY philosophy to burger construction, offering a basic variety for $9 and allowing you to upgrade it as you like, with traditional add-ons like caramelized onions (yum) and bacon (ditto) and somewhat outré options like avocado. The onions are sticky and sweet and the bacon meaty and formidable. And the entire combo, served inside an old-school foil wrapper, is enchanting, even if the temperature control is off. A satisfying halfway point between a fast food burger and a more imposing steakhouse version.

S’macks Burgers & Shakes-The Original

For a throwback with a locavore twist, order S’macks’ classic double-patty fast food burger tricked out with bison meat from Three Suns Ranch in Punta Gorda. The meat is topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, tangy “S’macks sauce” and your choice of more whimsical picks like jalapeños before being slapped between potato roll halves. It’s a subtly updated classic. Ground bison is leaner than traditional ground beef, so the patties are a little dry, but the flavor is outstanding, and the aridity is just an excuse to throw on some more of the house sauce.

Duffy’s cheeseburger

Duffy’s has been a Holmes Beach institution since 1958, and its burgers are still pulling in commuters from Sarasota and Tampa, as well as long-time islanders and kids back home from college. The restaurant has added some frou-frou options like blue cheese, caramelized onions and the like, but its calling card remains its standard cheeseburger. The meat is the star, with a peppered exterior that delivers a sting. Ideal fuel for a day on the sand.

BrewBurgers’ cheeseburger and fries

The grill gurus at BrewBurgers’ two Venice locations are expert searers, adept at keeping thin patties pink and juicy while scarring their exteriors to blackened beauty. A tender, floury bun hugs the patty and contains the lettuce and tomato and a fistful of shredded lettuce. These burgers are a perfect accompaniment to the restaurant’s excellent selection of local beers. The menu gets adventurous and even a bit odd with toppings like mushrooms, tapenade and Buffalo sauce, but we prefer the straight-up, lactose-heavy classic.
Blu Island Bistro’s Daily Bistro Burger

You never know what chef Alan Laskowski has in store until you belly up at his charming Venice eatery and ask what’s what. The Daily Bistro Burger may not change every day, but Laskowski mixes it up at least every few days. On a recent visit, the beef lay beneath a pile of sweet, charred pulled pork, a strip of bacon and some dripping cheese. If it sounds like a bit much, that’s because it was. But we finished every bite, and we’ll be back again soon to taste what Laskowski cooks up next.

Patrick’s 1481 Bacon Cheeseburger

An institution. For years, Patrick’s hoarded best burger awards from local media outlets, delivering solid, straightforward combos built around patties that would come red in the middle if you so desired. The restaurant moved down the street to its current digs after 25 years in its previous Five Points home but made sure to bring those burgers with it. There may be more creative burgers out there today, but a throwback Patrick’s patty still has the capacity to wow, particularly on Mondays, when the eatery slashes the price to an absurd $5.

Published By Sarasota Magazine

READ MORE ARTICLES

Construction Complete at BLVD Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Construction Complete at BLVD Sarasota

Limited Opportunities Remain Sarasota, FL, August 24, 2020 – CORE Development, Inc. announced BLVD Sarasota, the company’s new, luxury high-rise… Read more »

9 Best Things to Do in Sarasota BLVD SArasota

9 Best Things to Do in Sarasota

There’s no doubt that Sarasota has some of the most impressive attractions in all Florida. From art museums to outdoor… Read more »

Which of these BLVD Sarasota Floorplans would you want to call home? BLVD SArasota

Which of these BLVD Sarasota Floorplans would you want to call home?

Sarasota’s most exciting new downtown address is currently under construction and almost ready for move-in. It’s a lifestyle like no… Read more »

The Top Five Places to Soak Up the Sun in Sarasota BLVD SArasota

The Top Five Places to Soak Up the Sun in Sarasota

Sarasota is a city of people who love the outdoors. Whether you’re seeking to swim and sun atop the rooftop… Read more »

5 Reasons Sarasota Is Always a Great Place to Live BLVD SArasota

5 Reasons Sarasota Is Always a Great Place to Live

There are many reasons to love calling Sarasota home. For those who are “staying at home” here, it’s a pretty… Read more »

On-site Restaurant Brings Unbelievable Perks for BLVD Sarasota Residents BLVD SArasota

On-site Restaurant Brings Unbelievable Perks for BLVD Sarasota Residents

The Sarasota area is known, among other things, for its extraordinary culinary scene. And now, the area’s newest and most… Read more »

BLVD Sarasota, the perfect balance of design, location and timing BLVD SArasota

BLVD Sarasota, the perfect balance of design, location and timing

Sarasota is one of the most unique and dynamic cities in the nation. It’s no surprise that so many people… Read more »

What Sarasota Native Will Play in the Super Bowl 2020? BLVD SArasota

What Sarasota Native Will Play in the Super Bowl 2020?

It’s always nostalgic to see our local natives make the limelight. So, do you know which NFL football player from… Read more »

Unique Things About BLVD Sarasota You Would Never Expect BLVD SArasota

Unique Things About BLVD Sarasota You Would Never Expect

BLVD Sarasota is the area’s most exciting new residence tower that has so much to offer, especially when it comes… Read more »

Must-See Sarasota Historical Attractions BLVD SArasota

Must-See Sarasota Historical Attractions

Here in Sarasota, history co-exists side by side with modern-day buildings and technologies. More than just eye-catching landmarks, these historical… Read more »

Raising Luxury to a Higher Standard at BLVD Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Raising Luxury to a Higher Standard at BLVD Sarasota

Located in Sarasota, Florida, BLVD Sarasota hosts a variety of world-class amenities, each designed to cater to the unique things… Read more »

Unique Adventures in Sarasota You Would Never Expect BLVD SArasota

Unique Adventures in Sarasota You Would Never Expect

There are several exceptional ways to see historic and beautiful Sarasota. From touring the sprawling Ca’ d’Zan to surveying the… Read more »

Are Low Florida Taxes Creating a Boom in Sarasota? You Bet! BLVD SArasota

Are Low Florida Taxes Creating a Boom in Sarasota? You Bet!

What is it exactly that moves people to move to Florida? The idea of spending a winter enjoying temperatures at… Read more »

Ever Think You Would Explore Sarasota Like This? BLVD SArasota

Ever Think You Would Explore Sarasota Like This?

Smartphone audio tours are one of the ways that tourism is becoming more modern, allowing thrill-seekers to discover the city… Read more »

Out on the Town in Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Out on the Town in Sarasota

Sarasota, Florida has always been a cultural powerhouse. Some would chalk it up to its artistic history that has even… Read more »

These Expansive Condo Floor Plans Make Living In This Gulf Coast Town Even More Upscale BLVD SArasota

These Expansive Condo Floor Plans Make Living In This Gulf Coast Town Even More Upscale

Everyone wants a piece of Sarasota, Florida. Art lovers, culture seekers, adrenaline junkies, and travelers from across the globe head… Read more »

Play Golf Any Time at BLVD Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Play Golf Any Time at BLVD Sarasota

Sarasota, Florida has been called ‘The Cradle of Golf’. Players from across the globe gather to play here and improve… Read more »

Forbes Picks Sarasota as One of the Best Places to Retire BLVD SArasota

Forbes Picks Sarasota as One of the Best Places to Retire

Forbes Magazine has recently recognized Sarasota on its list of ‘The Best Places To Retire In 2019’. The magazine itself… Read more »

Sarasota: The Shelling Capital of the World BLVD SArasota

Sarasota: The Shelling Capital of the World

From scallops to sand dollars, Florida owes its diverse collection of shells to the water currents that flow around the… Read more »

The Beach Bistro and the BLVD Sarasota Culinary Community BLVD SArasota

The Beach Bistro and the BLVD Sarasota Culinary Community

Other buildings have a restaurant. BLVD Sarasota has THE culinary dining experience. The Beach Bistro will be creating a sibling… Read more »

Where is the best Waterfront Dining in Sarasota? BLVD SArasota

Where is the best Waterfront Dining in Sarasota?

There’s no doubt that Sarasota has one of the most influential dining scenes in the region. Restaurants of all kinds… Read more »

It is Turtle Nesting Season in Florida! Here is Everything you Need to Know. BLVD SArasota

It is Turtle Nesting Season in Florida! Here is Everything you Need to Know.

May might mark the end of season in Florida, but for the locals who live in Sarasota and along Lido… Read more »

Shop ‘Til You Drop Sarasota Style BLVD SArasota

Shop ‘Til You Drop Sarasota Style

Sarasota is known for its amazing natural landscapes, its all-encompassing cultural history, and its amazing shopping. From Palm Avenue boutiques… Read more »

Top 25 Best Places to Live in the U.S. BLVD SArasota

Top 25 Best Places to Live in the U.S.

Cheers to Sarasota for earning a spot on U.S. News & World Report’s ‘25 Best Places To Live in the… Read more »

Can’t Miss Sarasota Fireworks Displays BLVD SArasota

Can’t Miss Sarasota Fireworks Displays

This is the time of year to go all out. Fortunately, the city of Sarasota is well equipped to handle… Read more »

Best Spas in Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Best Spas in Sarasota

With so many parks, shopping centers, restaurants, and great beaches, Sarasota, Florida has so much to do that sometimes the… Read more »

Memorial Day Events in Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Memorial Day Events in Sarasota

There are a few standout events this Memorial Day weekend that Sarasota area residents may wish to attend. Patriot Plaza… Read more »

5 Things That You Should Know About Luxury Condominium Real Estate BLVD SArasota

5 Things That You Should Know About Luxury Condominium Real Estate

There’s all kinds of information out there about the luxury condominium market. What many buyers don’t know, is that while… Read more »

Gorgeous Trails Near Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Gorgeous Trails Near Sarasota

When you’re in a city like Sarasota, with as much man made and natural beauty, you can’t pass up a… Read more »

Top 3 Keys Near Sarasota, Florida BLVD SArasota

Top 3 Keys Near Sarasota, Florida

When you think of keys, the first thing that comes to mind are the small, eclectic, vibrant islands that lie… Read more »

Knighthead Fundings break its own record with FL funding of BLVD Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Knighthead Fundings break its own record with FL funding of BLVD Sarasota

Greenwich, CT-based Knighthead Funding has closed on its biggest loan since the company’s founding in 2014 Jonathan Daniel, principal of… Read more »

Allegiant Begins Service to Seven New Cities from SRQ BLVD SArasota

Allegiant Begins Service to Seven New Cities from SRQ

The airline now flies to a total of 12 cities from Sarasota-Bradenton International Airport. Allegiant Airlines has added service to… Read more »

Top 4 Events in Sarasota This April BLVD SArasota

Top 4 Events in Sarasota This April

April is one of the best times to be in Sarasota. The weather is mild and the city is full… Read more »

30 Restaurants Within 5 Blocks of BLVD Sarasota BLVD SArasota

30 Restaurants Within 5 Blocks of BLVD Sarasota

You’re never far from flavor when you’re living at this upscale downtown Sarasota high rise. See what dining delights are… Read more »

Do You Know Where to Find the Best Dog Parks in Sarasota? BLVD SArasota

Do You Know Where to Find the Best Dog Parks in Sarasota?

Many agree that dogs are far more than just furry companions. They are friends who walk the path of life with… Read more »

Take Me Out to the Ball Game – It’s Spring Training Time in Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Take Me Out to the Ball Game – It’s Spring Training Time in Sarasota

The great weather doesn’t bring just culture seekers and permanent vacationers – it also heralds the beginning of spring training…. Read more »

Sarasota Sunset Spots You Have to See to Believe BLVD SArasota

Sarasota Sunset Spots You Have to See to Believe

It’s only fitting that the Sunshine State would have jaw-dropping sunsets. Thanks to its prime location on the west coast… Read more »

Top Brunch Spots in Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Top Brunch Spots in Sarasota

Sarasota, located on the west coast of Florida, naturally draws people in, thanks to its beautiful beaches, its amazing history… Read more »

A Surge of New $2-Million-Plus Condos Lifts the Sarasota Real Estate Market BLVD SArasota

A Surge of New $2-Million-Plus Condos Lifts the Sarasota Real Estate Market

A string of ultra-luxury condominium projects are filling in the downtown Sarasota skyline: Auteur, Blvd, Epoch, the Ritz-Carlton Residences at… Read more »

Garth Brooks is in Bradenton playing baseball with the Pittsburgh Pirates for spring training BLVD SArasota

Garth Brooks is in Bradenton playing baseball with the Pittsburgh Pirates for spring training

Garth Brooks has come out of baseball retirement. The country music legend will spend just over a week participating in… Read more »

Fun Facts You Didn’t Know About Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Fun Facts You Didn’t Know About Sarasota

To know Sarasota is to love Sarasota.  How many of these facts did you already know? Sarasota is a truly… Read more »

Beach Bistro’s Award-Winning Chef to Open New Location Downtown Sarasota BLVD SArasota

Beach Bistro’s Award-Winning Chef to Open New Location Downtown Sarasota

As an artistic and cultural city, creators of all kinds bring luxury details, specialized techniques and quality ingredients to Sarasota…. Read more »

February Events You Won’t Want To Miss in Sarasota BLVD SArasota

February Events You Won’t Want To Miss in Sarasota

There is always so much to do near BLVD Sarasota. We narrowed down a few of our favorite events here…. Read more »

Sarasota High School Football Player to Hit the Field Tonight at Super Bowl LIII BLVD SArasota

Sarasota High School Football Player to Hit the Field Tonight at Super Bowl LIII

High school rankings aren’t everything, but sometimes top players continue to excel into adulthood. Super Bowl LIII features 5 players… Read more »

Sarasota’s Coolest Coffee Shops – Take the Tour BLVD SArasota

Sarasota’s Coolest Coffee Shops – Take the Tour

Sarasota is so full of things to do that you won’t want to miss a thing. From art shows to… Read more »

Sarasota’s Most Sought After Interior Designers BLVD SArasota

Sarasota’s Most Sought After Interior Designers

It’s no surprise that the residents of Sarasota have a deep appreciation for art and culture. The city’s history has… Read more »

The New Downtown Sarasota – Learn About What’s Coming BLVD SArasota

The New Downtown Sarasota – Learn About What’s Coming

New Development in Sarasota Head to Sarasota’s downtown area, and within minutes, you’ll be surrounded by art, boutique stores, and… Read more »

What to Look For When Choosing A Luxury Residence BLVD SArasota

What to Look For When Choosing A Luxury Residence

The benefits of owning a luxury maintenance-free condominium in the heart of Sarasota are numerous. You’re close to the vibrant… Read more »

A List of Sarasota’s Favorite Local Artists BLVD SArasota

A List of Sarasota’s Favorite Local Artists

Sarasota is a land of natural beauty. The city is painted in bright colors and decorated in its unique architectural… Read more »

4 Places Worth Exploring in Sarasota Florida BLVD SArasota

4 Places Worth Exploring in Sarasota Florida

If you ask anyone where the best spot in Sarasota is, they’ll each have a different answer. The city is… Read more »